The 7 Most Common Mistakes When Restoring a Historic Home (And How to Avoid Them)

Restoring a historic home is one of the most rewarding projects you can take on as a homeowner. It’s a chance to breathe new life into a property that holds stories, craftsmanship, and architectural details from another era. However, with all the excitement and potential comes a set of unique challenges that can derail your project if you’re not careful. That’s why I’ve created a comprehensive guide in my latest video, "STOP Wasting Time on These 7 Restoration Mistakes!"

Restoring a historic home is one of the most rewarding projects you can take on. It’s a chance to breathe new life into a property filled with stories, craftsmanship, and architectural details from another era. However, with all the excitement and potential comes a set of unique challenges that can derail your project if you’re not careful. That’s why we created our latest video, "STOP Wasting Time on These 7 Restoration Mistakes!"

In this blog post, we’ll walk you through the critical restoration mistakes you need to avoid and share how following the right steps can save you time, money, and a lot of headaches. If you’re tackling a historic home restoration, this guide (and the video) is a must-read to help keep your project on track while preserving the integrity of your home.

1. Rushing the Process: Restoration Is a Marathon, Not a Sprint

One of the biggest pitfalls in historic home restoration is rushing the process. It’s easy to get swept up in the excitement of the project and want everything done quickly. But restoring a historic property requires patience. Taking the time to plan, research, and carefully execute each step will prevent costly mistakes down the road. 

2. Using the Wrong Materials: The Devil Is in the Details

Materials can make or break a historic restoration. Modern materials might seem like a convenient choice, but they often clash with the original character of the home and can even damage its structure. Using inappropriate replacements for windows, flooring, or siding can strip away the historical essence of your property. 

3. Ignoring Structural Issues: Don’t Just Focus on Aesthetics

It’s tempting to start with the cosmetic changes—new paint, fixtures, and furnishings. But without addressing the foundational aspects first, you’re building on shaky ground. Structural issues like a sagging roof, deteriorating beams, or foundation cracks can turn into expensive problems if left unchecked. 

4. Skipping Historical Research: Every Home Has a Story

One of the most fascinating parts of restoring a historic home is uncovering its past. Skipping this step not only robs you of the opportunity to connect with your property’s unique history but can also lead to design choices that don’t align with its original style. Conducting thorough historical research helps you make informed decisions that enhance the authenticity of your restoration.

5. Over-Restoring or Overmodernizing: Keep the Charm Intact

Finding the balance between modern comfort and historical authenticity can be tricky. Over-restoring a property—adding too many modern touches—can strip away its historical charm and make it feel like any other new home. 

6. Neglecting Permits and Regulations: Don’t Skip the Red Tape

Permits and regulations might seem like a hassle, but they exist for a reason, especially when dealing with historic properties. Each area has its own set of rules for preserving historic structures, and skipping these steps can lead to fines, project delays, or even legal battles.

7. DIYing Everything: Know When to Call the Pros

There’s a certain pride that comes with doing restoration work yourself, but taking on everything can quickly become overwhelming. Historic homes often require specialized knowledge that only experienced professionals possess. Whether it’s dealing with lead paint, plaster restoration, or period-accurate woodworking, knowing when to DIY and when to bring in the experts is key to a successful project. 

Bonus Tips: Preserving the Historic Charm Without the Headaches

Beyond avoiding these common pitfalls, there are a few extra steps you can take to ensure your restoration project is a success. In the video, we offer bonus tips that include:

• How to protect the original features of your home during renovation.
• Creative ways to update your home without sacrificing its historical value.
• Resources and communities where you can connect with other historic home enthusiasts.

Watch the Full Video: "STOP Wasting Time on These 7 Restoration Mistakes!"

Ready to dive deeper and avoid these costly restoration mistakes? Check out our latest video, where we break down each of these points in more detail, share real-life examples, and provide expert tips to help guide your restoration journey.

👉 Watch the Full Video on YouTube Here

Don’t Forget to Subscribe!
If you’re passionate about historic homes and want more restoration advice, historic home tours, and insider tips, make sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel, History Loves Company. Together, we can keep history alive, one home at a time.

Join the Conversation: Share Your Restoration Stories

We’d love to hear about your own restoration projects! Have you encountered any of these common mistakes? Share your experiences in the comments below, and let’s help each other navigate the ups and downs of historic home restoration.

Remember, every home has a story. Let’s discover yours and preserve its legacy for generations to come.